Shelter Island Genealogy (in Suffolk County)
Cemetery Records
Ancient Long Island epitaphs from the towns of Southold, Shelter Island, and Easthampton, New York Family History LibraryAncient Long Island, New York, cemeteries, 1677-1807 Family History Library
Emily F French Memorial Cemetery Find a Grave
Presbyterian Church Burial Ground Find a Grave
Saint Marys Episcopal Church Cemetery Find a Grave
Shelter Island Cemetery Jane Devlin
Shelter Island Presbyterian Cemetery Interment
Sylvester Manor & Sachem Neck Cemeteries Long Island Genealogy
Sylvester Manor Burial Ground Find a Grave
Church Records
A chronicle of Shelter Island's churches Family History LibraryHistorical Papers on Shelter Island and its Presbyterian Church (includes family genealogies) Long Island Genealogy
Genealogies
Historical Papers on Shelter Island and its Presbyterian Church (includes family genealogies) Long Island GenealogyHistorical Records
Index to Ralph G. Duvall's The history of Shelter Island Family History LibraryThe history of Shelter Island : from its settlement in 1652, to the present time, 1932
The history of Shelter Island, from its settlement in 1652 to the present time, 1932 Family History Library
The smallest village : the story of Dering Harbor, Shelter Island, New York, 1874-1974 Family History Library
The story of Shelter Island in the Revolution Family History Library